top of page
IMG_8608.jpeg

What Bangladesh Loses by Denying Its Indigenous Peoples

Logo.jpg
  • YouTube
What Bangladesh LoosesArtist Name
00:00 / 28:26

Didi stands quietly watching as the younger Garo girls perform a traditional welcome dance for their guests in Nalikhali. Across generations, culture finds its continuity, not in museums or written records, but through the people who practise it, adapt it and pass it on. For these young women, the dance is both an expression of their heritage and an opportunity to share it with the wider world.

Bangladesh's failure to recognise its Indigenous peoples carries a cost far beyond cultural identity. In a Garo village in the country's north, a community is demonstrating what becomes possible when people retain control of their knowledge, land, and livelihoods.

By Dr Tom Corcoran

Published by ETHNOMAD

Bangladesh is home to more than 54 Indigenous peoples, speaking at least 35 languages, with histories, traditions and relationships with the land that long predate the modern nation. Yet the country does not formally recognise them as Indigenous peoples.

​

The state officially lists 50 ethnic communities under its Small Ethnic Cultural Institutions Act, while Article 23A of the Constitution acknowledges the cultures and traditions of what it calls "tribes, minor races, ethnic sects and communities."

​

The distinction is more consequential than it might first appear. The Constitution commits the state to protecting these cultures, but does not establish corresponding recognition of Indigenous identity or collective rights over customary lands and resources. There is a considerable difference between recognising that a people have a culture and recognising their right to determine its future.

​

This is not simply a question of terminology. It concerns land, education, economic opportunity, environmental management and the ability of communities to maintain their identities within a rapidly changing country.

It also raises a question that receives remarkably little attention: What has Bangladesh itself lost by failing to recognise and invest in the potential of its Indigenous peoples?

​

I have been exploring that question in Nalikhali, a Garo village in northern Bangladesh, where a modest, community-rooted enterprise is beginning to show possibilities that conventional approaches to development often overlook.

​

Gumi earns around 500 BDT for a day of agricultural labour. Over a weekend, his wife Didi and their daughter Prakriti can earn 4,000 BDT between them through The Garo Experience. That is the equivalent of eight days of his wages, earned close to home. Any profit from the enterprise is separate. The figures are modest, but the difference in opportunity matters.

​

The enterprise has just two guest rooms, yet its bookings are already creating paid work for cooks, cleaners, dancers, guides, weavers and local farmers, with much of that work going to women and girls. Before the first visitors arrived, six months of construction had brought thousands of dollars into local businesses and households. Labourers gained practical experience in woodworking, bricklaying and other building skills.

​

The economic activity began long before the first paying guest slept in a bed. The land and buildings belong to the women of the Dibru family. Through ETHNOMAD, I contributed capital, practical guidance and labour to help establish the enterprise. Much of my work has also involved documenting Garo life, including the knowledge and practices being maintained, those being lost and others being recovered or adapted.

IMG_8698.heic

Prakriti carefully skins a freshly caught eel for Didi to prepare in the family kitchen at Nalikhali. What appears to be a simple household task is also part of how knowledge passes between generations.

Learning to handle local ingredients, prepare traditional foods and understand the resources of the surrounding landscape is part of growing up Garo. These everyday moments, rarely recorded or celebrated, are where much of a culture's living knowledge survives.

At ETHNOMAD, we do not think or talk in terms of beneficiaries. We work with owners.

 

This is more than a preference for different language. It reflects a different starting point for development.

​

ETHNOMAD is not an NGO in the conventional sense. I have spent much of my professional life working in humanitarian assistance and development, and have witnessed both the considerable achievements of that work and its limitations.

​

Too often, development begins with an assessment of what people lack. Organisations identify problems, develop proposals, secure funding and deliver activities to communities whose participation is then recorded as evidence of success.

​

There is another way to begin: by understanding what people already possess. Through conservation ethnography, we discover that knowledge, land, language, culture, relationships, practical skills, and ambitions are all forms of wealth, even when they are not recognised in conventional economic assessments.

​

Sometimes realising their potential requires investment. Sometimes it involves access to markets, technical knowledge, practical labour or simply working through a problem together. It also requires accepting that people have priorities of their own, which may differ considerably from those of donors and outside organisations. 

​

Ownership changes the relationship. People make decisions, take risks, generate income and build something that can remain theirs. Not everybody working within an enterprise is a legal owner. At Nalikhali, family ownership of the land and buildings is distinct from the paid opportunities created for the wider community.

 

But the principle remains important: economic development should strengthen local ownership and decision-making, rather than transfer control of cultural and natural resources to outsiders.

And the enterprise itself is only part of the story.

​

Didi, Prakriti, Purnita, Bizuli and Suvra, together with dozens of other local people, are offering visitors a Bangladesh they may never have encountered.

The Garo Experience is built around a community, not simply a guesthouse. Its character comes from the women who prepare traditional food, the weavers who maintain their skills, the farmers who cultivate the land, the musicians and dancers, the elders who share their memories, and the families who welcome strangers into their world.

​

The rooms provide somewhere to sleep. The community makes the experience possible. Without its people, their knowledge, relationships and willingness to share their lives, there would be little more than accommodation in a rural village. The exchange is not one-sided.​ Visitors arrive with curiosity, but that curiosity travels in both directions. New relationships emerge, ideas are exchanged, and opportunities develop that extend beyond tourism.

​

English becomes useful around a shared table. Weaving finds customers. Growing fresh food supplies the kitchen. Young people have reasons to learn about the world beyond Nalikhali while explaining their own.

​

Even before the enterprise was fully operating, visitors had contributed towards establishing a teacher training centre intended to strengthen local education. A relationship created an opportunity that extended well beyond the cost of a stay. None of this happens without friction.

​

One of our earliest difficulties was determining which produce was grown without synthetic chemicals and which came from farms that used them. Local food could not automatically be described as organic. We needed to understand cultivation methods and supply chains. Other questions went deeper. Which ingredients and practices were traditionally Garo? Which had changed? Which had disappeared? Who remembered them, and who was still practising them?

 

Across the border in India, Garo dress and dance can offer a striking contrast with what I encounter in Bangladesh.

​

In the Bengali-dominated markets of northern Bangladesh, traditional forms of Garo dress can attract unwanted attention. Women continue to wear bright colours and familiar patterns, but often adapt their clothing to cover their arms and legs. When a woman feels unsafe wearing certain traditional garments in public, such adaptations cannot be understood entirely as matters of individual preference.

​

Culture changes everywhere. But there is a difference between changes freely chosen and changes made under social pressure, insecurity or exclusion. The question is not whether Garo culture should change. It is whether Garo people have the freedom to determine how it changes.

At Nalikhali, Didi sources as much of her kitchen produce as possible from the family’s land and neighbouring Garo farmers. For ingredients she cannot grow or obtain locally, she has begun building a trusted network of Bengali farmers who use organic growing methods. Here, she carefully checks a delivery of freshly harvested roots, weighed on a traditional balance. Building these relationships has taken time, particularly in distinguishing produce grown without synthetic chemicals from that produced through conventional farming. It is a small but important part of The Garo Experience: supporting local livelihoods, building trust between communities and understanding where food comes from before it reaches the table.

IMG_8825.heic

We make changes at Nalikhali too.

​

Visitors need comfortable accommodation, and food preferences must be understood. The kitchen has raised working surfaces rather than requiring women to prepare everything at ground level. Traditional ingredients and cooking knowledge remain central, while staff develop skills in food safety, hygiene and hospitality that could also be useful in a modern urban restaurant.

​

This is not the abandonment of tradition. It is the practical negotiation between inherited knowledge and contemporary needs. Preserving a culture should not mean expecting people to live permanently as their ancestors did. Nor should cultural tourism turn Indigenous communities into living museums, performing an imagined past for paying visitors.

​

A living culture must be allowed to develop. Yet the ability to direct that development depends on something more fundamental than tourism or cultural pride: security over land and resources. For Garo communities, homestead forests, agricultural land and surrounding landscapes hold generations of practical knowledge. Plants provide food, medicines and materials. Farming and forest management practices carry understandings of soils, seasons and local ecology that are rarely captured in formal development statistics.

​

Similar relationships exist among Indigenous peoples throughout Bangladesh, from the plains of Greater Mymensingh and Sylhet to the Chittagong Hill Tracts. But customary relationships with land do not necessarily translate into enforceable legal rights. In the Chittagong Hill Tracts, the 1997 Accord established a framework intended to address longstanding disputes over land and governance, but significant provisions remain unresolved. For Indigenous communities in the plains, comparable mechanisms to recognise customary land tenure and resolve disputes are largely absent.

​

This is one of the consequences of the wider failure to recognise Indigenous peoples as distinct rights-bearing communities. Recognition alone would not resolve every land dispute, just as recognition elsewhere has not eliminated discrimination or dispossession. But it provides a foundation for acknowledging customary institutions, collective claims and the principle that people should have a meaningful say in decisions affecting their ancestral lands.

​

Without effective protection, land can be leased, acquired or converted to other uses while customary interests receive inadequate consideration. Development projects may proceed without communities having sufficient authority to influence decisions that permanently alter their livelihoods.

​

The proposed tourism development at Chimbuk Hill in the Chittagong Hill Tracts, for example, has raised concerns among Mro communities about farmland, forests, water sources, cultural sites and the absence of adequate consultation and consent. There is an uncomfortable contradiction in promoting tourism and development while the people whose land and cultural heritage make a place distinctive may have limited power over what happens there.

​

These are not abstract legal problems. When people cannot securely hold land, they become less able to invest in it, protect its resources or pass it to future generations. A forest can be cleared once for timber, or managed to provide food, materials, livelihoods and ecological services over generations. Land can become an asset for an outside investor, or remain the foundation of an Indigenous family's economic future. Those decisions determine who acquires wealth and who bears the cost of its loss.

​

Look across the border to Meghalaya in India. Its tourism policy recognises the importance of Khasi, Garo and Jaintia customary institutions and the community relationships that govern forests, waterways and cultural landscapes. Sacred groves, living root bridges and traditional villages are understood not only as heritage, but also as foundations for tourism and local economic activity.

​

Meghalaya has its own difficulties, and recognition does not guarantee equitable development. Nevertheless, its policy framework offers a useful contrast with Bangladesh, particularly in acknowledging the place of customary governance and community ownership in economic planning. Elsewhere, the contribution of Indigenous cultural enterprises is measurable.

​

In Canada, Indigenous tourism generated an estimated C$3.7 billion in revenue in 2023, directly contributing around C$1.6 billion to national GDP and supporting approximately 34,700 direct jobs.

​

In New Zealand, Māori tourism contributed approximately NZ$1.2 billion to GDP in the same year.

In Australia, close to 1.25 million international visitor trips included an Indigenous experience in the year ending March 2026. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures are promoted as an integral part of the country's national identity and international tourism appeal.

​

These figures do not establish what Indigenous tourism could earn in Bangladesh. The countries differ considerably in infrastructure, purchasing power, tourism markets and public investment.

​

But they demonstrate something important. Indigenous culture is not simply a heritage concern requiring preservation funding. It can contribute to employment, enterprise, national income and international understanding when the people whose cultures create that value retain a meaningful role in controlling it.

And tourism is only one part of the opportunity.

 

IMG_8624.heic

Indigenous chef Arpon Chakma exchanges culinary knowledge and ideas with Garo cooks Didi and Bizuli at The Garo Experience in Nalikhali. Although their communities have distinct culinary traditions, they share a deep understanding of food drawn from the land: fresh forest vegetables, seasonal plants, bamboo shoots, locally grown ingredients and cooking methods passed down through generations. Around the table, knowledge moves between communities, with each bringing something to learn and something to share. It is a reminder that Indigenous knowledge is not confined to the past. It remains alive through practice, exchange and the willingness to learn from one another.

Traditional agricultural knowledge, ecological management, weaving, food production, medicinal plants, forest stewardship and cultural education all carry potential value. Some may support commercial enterprises; others are essential to maintaining healthy landscapes, secure livelihoods and knowledge that would be difficult or impossible to recover once lost. Bangladesh has considerable potential in these fields, but much of it remains poorly understood.

​

How many international visitors come specifically for cultural experiences? How much revenue reaches Indigenous-owned enterprises? How much traditional ecological knowledge contributes to forest management and local food systems? How many communities possess the legal and economic security needed to develop enterprises of their own? Without reliable information, it is difficult to calculate the opportunity being lost.

​

I suspect the cumulative economic cost of decades of neglect is substantial, potentially amounting to billions when foregone income, weakened productive assets and lost opportunities are considered. But that proposition requires serious economic investigation. It cannot responsibly be presented as an established national loss.

The absence of such accounting is itself revealing.

​

We can measure the market value of timber, the output of a factory or the income of a commercial farm. Yet the contribution of maintaining a forest through customary stewardship, passing on agricultural knowledge or sustaining a distinctive cultural identity rarely receives the same attention.

​

Some of these contributions may be measurable through ecosystem services, avoided costs, employment or local production. Others cannot meaningfully be reduced to money. Nor should every cultural practice have to demonstrate a financial return to deserve protection. A people's right to maintain their identity is not conditional on whether tourists wish to visit them.

Nevertheless, there are economic consequences when those rights are neglected.

​

Loss of land can undermine livelihoods and reduce the incentive or capacity for long-term stewardship. Language loss can weaken the transmission of knowledge. Cultural exclusion can discourage young people from retaining skills that might otherwise contribute to viable enterprises. Poor educational opportunities can leave them less able to negotiate the economic changes taking place around them.

​

These costs accumulate across generations. They affect Indigenous communities first, but their consequences extend to the wider country through lost production, diminished biodiversity, weakened social cohesion and the disappearance of knowledge that could contribute to national development.

​

The failure is not merely that Bangladesh overlooks potential commercial opportunities. It is that national development can proceed while diminishing some of the very resources, relationships and cultural strengths upon which a more inclusive future might be built.

There have been encouraging developments.

​

In 2025, the Bangladesh Tourism Board and the International Labour Organization (ILO) launched a community-based tourism initiative among Khasi communities at Jaflong. The programme introduced homestays, training and a community management structure intended to keep decision-making and economic opportunities within participating villages.

It is a useful beginning.

​

But cultural tourism, however carefully designed, cannot substitute for secure land rights, Indigenous recognition or meaningful authority over community resources. Nor can the language of community participation alone guarantee that people acquire enduring economic power.

​

For decades, international development organisations have worked with communities described as beneficiaries. The term is so thoroughly embedded in the industry's language that few pause to consider its implications. A beneficiary receives something. An organisation identifies a need, designs an intervention, controls the resources and evaluates the outcome.

​

That approach can be entirely appropriate in an emergency. Humanitarian assistance saves lives, and investment in healthcare, education and public services has produced substantial improvements in human welfare. I have spent much of my professional life working within that system. But emergency assistance and long-term economic development are not the same thing.

 

The model that delivers food after a flood is not necessarily the model that enables a family or community to accumulate productive assets and achieve lasting economic independence. Too often, communities are invited to participate in development projects without acquiring the ownership, capital, skills or decision-making authority required to continue independently. We establish committees, conduct consultations, prepare assessments and measure participation. Then the funding ends, the project closes, and another organisation arrives to begin a new cycle.

​

I call this danger "sustainable poverty": people remain engaged in development activity without acquiring the enduring rights, assets and security that would allow them to move beyond dependence.

 

The more useful questions are straightforward.​ Who owns the land? Who controls the enterprise? Who determines how cultural knowledge is used? Who receives the income? Who can refuse a proposal? What remains when the outside organisation leaves?

​

IMG_8454.heic

In the fading afternoon light, two Garo women walk a narrow country lane between the rice fields of Nalikhali. Far from the noise and relentless pace of Dhaka, life here follows a different rhythm, shaped by the seasons, the land and the relationships that hold a community together. Yet this apparent tranquillity conceals a more uncertain future. As Indigenous communities struggle for recognition and security over their ancestral lands, the countryside they have known for generations is changing. What is at stake is not simply a rural way of life, but the freedom of a people to remain themselves in a country that has yet to fully recognise who they are.

Representation on a committee does not settle those questions. Neither does calling a project community-based. There is also a responsibility to distinguish individual enterprise ownership from collective community rights. A successful family business cannot, by itself, resolve the insecurity of customary lands or guarantee that a whole community shares equally in economic gains.

​

Both forms of ownership are important, but they operate at different scales and require different protections. Development should ultimately reduce people's dependence on development organisations, not make that dependence permanent. Nalikhali offers a modest example of what may be possible, but it is not a finished model or a guaranteed success.

​

The enterprise is still developing. Bookings, costs, relationships and commercial pressures will test it. Cultural tourism brings risks of its own. Traditions can be simplified to meet visitor expectations, performances altered for commercial appeal and knowledge reduced to something that can be packaged and sold. Those risks cannot be dismissed merely because an enterprise is locally owned.

​

What matters is whether the people involved can negotiate those pressures themselves: deciding what to share, what to keep private, what to adapt and what should remain outside the marketplace. The women of Nalikhali are not attempting to recreate an earlier century. They are finding ways to live in this one, drawing upon their inheritance while acquiring new skills and economic opportunities.

That is a form of development worthy of attention.

​

But imagine what becomes possible when such efforts are supported by recognition of Indigenous identity, secure customary land rights, education that values Indigenous languages and national policies that treat Indigenous knowledge as a living resource rather than a remnant of the past. Bangladesh could develop a richer cultural tourism sector while supporting the agriculture, forest stewardship, crafts and locally owned enterprises that already exist within Indigenous communities.

​

More importantly, it could strengthen the conditions under which people can determine their own futures.

The country's opportunities extend far beyond the Garo of Nalikhali. The Chakma, Marma, Rakhine, Khasi, Santal, Tripura, Mro and many other Indigenous peoples carry distinct histories, languages, ecological knowledge and traditions that form part of Bangladesh's living inheritance. Their identities are not obstacles to national unity.

​

Being Garo, Rakhine, Chakma, Marma, Khasi or a member of another Indigenous people does not make someone less Bangladeshi. Recognition of their distinct histories and rights need not diminish their place within the nation.

A family should be able to earn more without leaving its village. A daughter should be able to learn English without losing her mother tongue. A community should be able to maintain its traditions without being excluded from modern economic life. And a forest should be worth protecting long before somebody calculates the price of its timber.

​

Bangladesh has spent decades pursuing development, with genuine achievements in healthcare, education, infrastructure and economic growth. Yet development should be judged not only by what a country builds, but also by what it allows to survive, flourish and contribute to its future.

 

There are many worlds within Bangladesh.

 

The tragedy is not simply that some of them may disappear. It is that Bangladesh may never fully understand what it has lost.

​

Experience Garo Life for Yourself

 

The story of the Garo is still being written, not only in words and photographs, but in the everyday lives of the people of Nalikhali.

The Garo Experience invites you to become part of that story. Stay with a Garo family, share traditional food, walk the village paths, meet local weavers and discover a living culture through the people who know it best.

​

This is more than a place to stay. It is an opportunity to build connections, exchange knowledge and contribute directly to a community-led enterprise.

he Garo Nalikhali Guesthouse.png
ff447188-197e-49af-ad69-e76e934981d3.JPG

Support Our Mission

​​​

  • Become a sponsor of the Fading Cultures project.

  • Support our magazine, films, expeditions, events, workshops and training courses.

  • Help us continue the cycle of conservation, restoration and documentation.

Contact

info@fadingcultures.org 

Nat Geo Logo
EXPED Sponsor Logo
Refugee Aid Logo
UCC Logo
Award
Conservation Livelihoods Int Logo
Rohingya Logo
Birmingham Logo
Sumatra Logo
UCD Logo
Pariaman Tourism Logo
Tourism Pariaman Logo
LA Indonesia Padang
bottom of page